Navigating the Northwest Passage

Navigating the Northwest Passage
May 25, 2007
July 31, 2007
Rauner Library, Class of 1965 Galleries

Curated by Tiffany Chang '09 & Nicole Stuckenberger

An exhibit poster featuring a historic illustration of two ships navigating icy waters near towering cliffs, titled “Navigating the Northwest Passage: Just Missing the Ice.”

Just Missing The Ice

The 19th century's quest for an Arctic Northwest Passage set the stage for men challenging the icy North Seas. Today, this epic still gives us insights into relationships of society to nature in a world that we are rapidly changing as the global temperatures are rising. Ice barriers are retreating and the Northwest Passage will be open to commercial shipping and resource exploitation. Drawing on the rich Stefansson Collection on Polar Exploration, this exhibition maps the quest for the "Arctic Grail."

The exhibition was curated by Ross Virginia, Tiffany Chang '09, and Nicole Stuckenberger and will be on display in the Class of 1965 Galleries in Rauner Library from May 25 to July 31, 2007.

You may download a small, 8x10 version of the poster: Northwest.jpg (2.5 MB) 

Handlist

Introduction

If you could gain fame exploring the Unknown and discover a dramatically shorter shipping route from Europe to Asia, what would you risk? And so begins the quest for a Northwest Passage -- an epic saga capturing human imaginations for over three centuries. It set the stage for men challenging the icy North Seas with the best but often ill-adapted technology of their day. Today, this epic still gives us insights into relationships between society and nature in a world that we are rapidly changing. 

Global warming opens an unanticipated chapter in the story of the Northwest Passage as our familiar world melts into a new Unknown. As the global temperatures are rising, ice barriers that had so often proven to be fatal obstacles to early maritime expeditions are retreating. On a timescale of decades, the Northwest Passage will be open to commercial shipping and resource exploitation. However, as icy barriers become less of an impediment to action, new issues merge. Present concerns involve geopoliticial debate on access control and resource exploitation, and environmental threats to northern communities and their lands.

Immerse yourself in a few chapters of this epic tale, which is now yours, too. While early explorers were thankful to 'miss the ice' -- will we?

  1. Virginia, R.; Yalowitz, K.; Krupnik, I.: Introduction: Perceptions of Arctic Climate Change. In Stuckenberger, N. (2007), Thin Ice: Inuit traditions within a Changing Environment. Exhibition catalogue of the Hood Museum of Art, Hanover, Dartmouth College. Hanover, London: UPNE. [not available at Rauner]
     
    1. Global Warming, Melting Ice, and Policy Making.
  2. Bockstoce, John. "Changing Images of the Northwest Passage." National Geographic, Aug. 1990. [not available at Rauner]
    1. Recent effects of resource exploration and military operations have often been detrimental to the Arctic environment and indigenous peoples whose cultures closely connect to them living off the land.
  3. Keating, Bern. "Through the Northwest Passage." The Lamp, Feb. 20, 1970. [not available at Rauner]
    1. In 1969, the SS Manhattan, carrying crude Alaskan oil, became the first commercial ship to successfully cross the Northwest Passage. Heavy ice floes made the trip difficult and rendered commercial shipping of Alaskan oil through the passage economically impractical. The Alaskan Pipeline was the better option at that time.

The Northwest Passage

The Northwest Passage is a sea route connecting the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans through the Arctic Archipelago of Canada. It is about 4,000 nautical miles, or or third of the overall distance, shorter than the Panama Canal route connecting Europe and the eastern American coasts with Asia. 

Case 1. Early Exploration -- William Edward Parry (1790) -- English Rear Admiral and Arctic Explorer

Early exploration of the ice-bound legendary Northwest Passage marked a thrilling period of discovery that was driven in part by the idea of taming the Arctic. Seafarers like William Edward Parry seized the opportunity to experience places and sights not previously traveled by Europeans. The explorers often showed stubbornness and ill-advised pride by not giving up European ways, such as of woolen clothing and military uniform, in the face of a much more demanding Arctic climate. The costs of human suffering, material loss, and loss of lives turned these journeys into heroic and often tragic epics.

Parry almost reached the 113th meridian and qualified for a £5,000 prize offered by the Board of Longitude to the first vessel that crossed the 110th meridian in high northern latitudes.

In 1821, his ships, the Hecla and the Griper, got caught in the ice and they became the first ships of the Royal Navy to winter in the Canadian Arctic. To keep their sanity, the men exercised by playing cricket on the ice and by running around the canvas-roofed deck to music from the ship's organ. Also, beer was brewed, a weekly newspaper was published, and the crew enjoyed comic theatrical performances each fortnight. 

During that winter, the crew made the acquaintance of a group of Inuit. They told Parry of a strait that led to a sea in the west. He never found the strait, but he brought home new knowledge of Arctic lands and Inuit way of life. 

  1. Parry, William Edward. Journal of a Third Voyage for the Discovery of a Northwest Passage from the Atlantic to the Pacific. London: John Murray: 1826. Stefansson G650 1824 .P3. Also available online via Hathi Trust.
     
    1. Situation of H. M. Ships Helca & Fury
  2. Griffith, William Nelson. Logbook, 1819-1820. Stefansson MSS 211.
    1. Midshipman William Griffith, who accompanied Parry on his first expedition to the Arctic, kept this logbook to record important detailed observations about weather conditions, location, and events. His notes provide us with valuable material for scientific comparison.
  3. Would you like to examine the progress made in land discovery within just a few years? Compare the two maps.
    1. Parry, William Edward. Journal of a Voyage for the Discovery of a Northwest Passage from the Atlantic to the Pacific. London: John Murray, 1821. Stefansson G650 1819 .P15. Also available online via Hathi Trust.
    2. Parry, William Edward. Journal of a Second Voyage for the Discovery of a Northwest Passage from the Atlantic to the Pacific. London: John Murray, 1824. Stefasson G650 1821 .P2

Case 2. The Franklin Disaster -- 1845-1848 HMS Erebus and HMS Terror and 134 men -- last seen July 26, 1845

Sir John Franklin was selected to lead a Naval expedition to uncover the remaining unknown parts of the Northwest Passage. His two ships, Erebus and the Terror, departed from England in May of 1845. They were stacked with pickled potatoes, pemmican, and a relatively new invention, canned meat (later discovered to be lethally poisoned with lead dissolving from the soldering of the cans). He reached Lancaster Sound, the gateway to Barrow's Straits, in August of that year, and was never seen again by Europeans.

The disappearance of Sir John Franklin (1786-1847) opened a new chapter of the Northwest Passage saga. Now, explorers had a humanitarian, practical, and pressing reason to escalate the page of Arctic exploration. In subsequent years, many ships sailed out of England with the purpose of finding and rescuing Franklin and his crew. As a result, knowledge of the Northwest Passage increased significantly, though little information about the missing Franklin expedition was ever recovered. 

  1. Welsh, George P. A Chart Illustrative of the Cruise of the American Arctic Expedition in Search of Sir John Franklin, in the Years 1850-1851. Washington, D.C.: United States Hydrographic Office, 1853. Stefansson G3270 1853 .W4
     
    1. This map marks the path taken by the American Arctic Expedition of 1850-1851, onboard two American ships Advance and Rescue that were commissioned for Franklin's search.
  2. Snow, William Parker. Voyage of the Prince Albert in Search of Sir John Franklin: A Narrative of Everyday Life in the Arctic Seas. London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, 1851. Stefansson G665 1850 .P9. Also available online via Hathi Trust.
     
    1. Except of a diary entry by William Parker Snow.
      1. Aug. 28, 1850
      2. 2:30 pm
      3. Men hear report of a gun on shore--I did not, but, though the captain laughed at the idea, he ordered the ship to be luffed up to  near the land ice, and our Howitzer was fired. I went aloft with our best spyglass,--closely and anxiously inspected the magnificent but high rocky coast and bays in vain,--strained by ears to catch any response to our signal--no sound but echo came back.
    2. "Admiral Sir John Ross' vessel, the "Felix," fast to the land ice--sketched at the time." William Parker Snow,  officer on board the Prince Albert in search of Franklin.
  3. Franklin, Lady Jane Griffith. Correspondence, 1850-1864. MSS-180.
    1. Excerpt from a letter by Lady Jane Franklin
      1. 21. Bedford Place
      2. London
      3. 26th Dec. of 1850
        1. Dear Sirs
        2. I have received with much gratitude and satisfaction your very obliging letter for the 3rd with offering to free passage of Mr. Kennedy, late of the Hudson's Bay Company, to England.
        3. I am daily in expectation of that gentleman, and should it so happen according to my wishes the 'Prince Albert' sail this spring and that Mr. Kennedy should be able to take the command of her, I should be more happy to communicate to him your very generous proposal ...
    2. Lady Jane Franklin remained highly involved with the search missions for her husband. One month later, another letter expresses her growing frustration and weariness with the current search for her missing husband.
  4. Stefansson, Vihjalmur, Papers. Stefansson Mss-98, Box LVI (56), Folder 24
    1. The loss of Franklin and his crew prompted huge media attention about Northwest Passage exploration, and the quest to find him generated a new human interest in the Arctic.
    2. Simultaneously, explorers also began to see the Northwest Passage for its potentially substantial economic value. As stated in the June 4, 1853 article of the Illustrated News, "Many of the islands that will come under notice ... will be thoroughly examined, not only as to their exact position,  but as to their commercial resources and advantages."

Case 3. A Disenchanted but Friendly Arctic -- Vihjalmur Stefansson -- Explorer (1879-1962) -- At Dartmouth 1947-1962

The end of the Franklin expeditions marked a turning point in the history of Arctic exploration. And age of remarkable discovery amidst devastating loss had come to a close, and new visions of the Arctic emerged. Stefansson, criticizing his predecessors for their ignorance of "Arctic Reality", effectively communicated to the public that the time for a more pragmatic view had arrived. In The Friendly Arctic (1921) he described the Arctic as a productive land as demonstrated by its indigenous population, the Inuit. While he emphasized the value of their traditional knowledge for everyone endeavoring to live in the Arctic, he also believed the Inuit did not make optimal use of their land by exploring the riches of unknown areas.

To Stefansson, the Arctic was not remote, and he emphasized its importance to the regions south, not the least because of its tremendous commercial potential. Among his many and sometimes controversial initiatives, Stefansson returned to the idea that the Northwest Passage could become a viable economic waterway using the information and technology then available. Beginning in  1932, Stefansson began mapping flight routes for Pan American Airlines and he worked on Charles Lindbergh's plan for a transatlantic flight. He also aided in the development of Alaska and northwestern Canada, particularly in oil prospecting and mapping of the Alaska Highway. Stefansson, in many respects, brought the Arctic closer to the modern world than ever. While he envisioned much of today's developments in the Arctic, what he could not foresee was that the Arctic environment itself would soon be drastically changing. 

  1. Stefansson, Vihjalmur. Stefansson Mss-98, Box 19 (map and memo)
    1. Stefansson suggests in a memo, Ships for Icy Seas, "The conclusion, then, is that relatively little change is required to make an ordinary oil tanker suitable for navigation of the Northeast and Northwest Passage."
  2. Stefansson, Vihjalmur. The Friendly Arctic. New York: the MacMillan Company, 1921. Stefansson G630.C2 S8. Also available online via Hathi Trust.
     
    1. Excerpt from Vihjalmur Stefansson's "The Friendly Arctic":
      1. "It may be a pity to destroy the illusion, for the world is getting daily poorer in romance. Elves and fairies no longer dance in the woods, and it appears a sort of vandalism to destroy the glamorous and heroic North by too intimate knowledge." (p. 8)
  3. Arctic photographs. Stefansson MSS-229, Boxes 3-4.
    1. Labels:
      1. Stefansson began his Arctic journey to meet and learn from the Inuit.
      2. Inuit have a holistic worldview. They believe, for example, that joy connects all levels of being.
      3. He learned what was of value to him.
        1. ...how to hunt and eat.
        2. ...how to provide shelter.
        3. ...how to travel. 
Back to top