Jentry Campbell, Engineering Librarian, with volumes from the Libraries' copies of The Discovery Commission Report
Whether Jentry scanned through a physical book from the Stefansson Collection or referred to digitized documentation, she found it “interesting and eye-opening how much we take for granted as being digitized.” In her search for answers to Yoshihiro’s research query, she encountered some issues with accessibility, legibility, formatting, and metadata, as well as trying to find information that was saved to “unfindable places.” And some of those older documents were missing, making it more challenging to trace and verify data.
“Unlike modern research papers, where you have a very contained structure, these older research trips were truly epic expeditions whose results were communicated to the public in long, narrative formats,” says Jentry. As such, Jentry had to investigate further to confirm sampling, storage, and measurement techniques of the expeditions’ findings. Jentry refined her search to ensure results were citable or had citations with them. She also leaned into her French language skills to translate some documents, using Google Translate to assist when what was written was less straightforward and for efficiency. Another challenge Jentry encountered was inconsistency.
Methods for how scientists collected data have changed over the centuries, making data validation and verification that much more difficult. Further, the volumes containing data points didn’t always detail the researchers’ methods, with related methodology documented in other volumes. Methodology and documentation variations can impact data points individually, which helps “explain away outliers” or lead researchers like Yoshihiro to have increased or decreased confidence in the data.